Science on the attosecond scale
Scientific contact: Stephen Leone, 510-486-4754
Among the most urgent challenges facing our nation are ways to use present energy sources far more efficiently while creating the carbon-free sources of the future. Artificial photosynthesis means mimicking the way nature does it, moving electrons through hundreds of superfast chemical steps; conserving electricity during transmission means building tough, flexible high-temperature superconductors; better solar cells depend on better ways for semiconductors to turn light energy into flowing electrons.
These and numerous other advances in energy, green chemistry, and human health must start with understanding the movement of electrons – making frame-by-frame movies of changing molecular bonds during chemical reactions, or the correlated behavior of electrons in complex solids. This will only be possible by freezing time within a few quintillionths of a second.
How is it possible to create pulses of light so short? Steve Leone, a pioneer in the field of ultrafast lasers, tells how it’s done.
When lasers that could emit ultrashort pulses of light became available in the 1980s, Steve Leone recalls, they ushered in a new field of “femtochemistry.” A femtosecond is a quadrillionth of a second, 10-15 second.
“From then until now, people have mostly studied relative atomic motions or the electronic transitions governed by these motions,” says Leone, a member of Berkeley Lab’s Chemical Sciences Division, a professor of chemistry and physics at UC Berkeley, and Director of the Chemical Dynamics Beamline at the Advanced Light Source. “These include vibrations, rotations, and the like – motions measured in timescales of femtoseconds.”
The fastest motion known between atomic nuclei is about eight femtoseconds, the vibrational period between the two hydrogen atoms in a hydrogen molecule. Electrons bind, release, and move among the atoms in a molecule or crystal, but almost all of the atom’s mass is in its nucleus, which drags its electrons around with it. So a lot of chemistry can be done by watching atoms move, even when their electrons can’t be seen directly.
But for Leone, femtoseconds don’t do the job. He wants to see electrons moving for themselves.
“Electrons are lighter and quicker and move in a much, much shorter time than nuclei,” Leone says. “Electron dynamics and electron correlation are the problems to be solved if we want to really understand and eventually control chemical processes and complex materials, such as high-speed electronics. To get at the electron dynamics directly, we need to work on the attosecond timescale.”
These thoughts motivated the start of the attosecond science program at Berkeley in 2004, a collaborative effort led by Leone and his colleague in UC Berkeley’s Chemistry Department, Daniel Neumark, Director of Berkeley Lab’s Chemical Sciences Division.
While there are more femtoseconds in a single second than there are seconds in 32 million years, attoseconds are a thousand times shorter yet – slices of time so fine that, while they can be counted and measured, they can hardly be imagined. In the time it takes a hydrogen molecule to make a single, vibratory bounce, its two electrons whiz around the molecule 300 times.
Catching these electrons in the act requires subfemtosecond laser pulses, from hundreds down to just a few attoseconds. How is it possible to create pulses of light so short? The secret lies in the intimate relationships between photons and electrons. Photons give electrons energy; under certain conditions, the electrons can give back that energy and more.
Surfing light to make faster light
Imagine a red or near-infrared laser pulse (its long wavelengths are called “optical” wavelengths); the waves of the pulse’s electromagnetic field rise and fall like surf, and as it drives through a medium such as pressurized neon gas, the rising wave lifts electrons out of their orbits around atoms and accelerates them toward freedom.
The intensity of the driver pulse isn’t always sufficient to permanently ionize the gas, however. Often, before the electrons can escape, the wave crests and reverses; the electrons are drawn back and reaccelerate into the atoms, carrying the extra energy they gained from the electromagnetic field.
Upon recombination, the atom emits a burst of higher-frequency (ultraviolet or x-ray) light measured in attoseconds. As electrons continue to recombine, the process repeats with each half wave of the optical cycle, making a sequence of bright, high-frequency attosecond flashes, perfectly synchronized with the optical driver’s wave frequency, carrying them along in the same direction.
This three-step process – electron acceleration away from the atom, acceleration back to the atom, and recombination that emits an attosecond flash – is called high harmonic generation.
“High harmonic generation is one basic and most common way of creating an attosecond laser pulse,” says Leone. “If the pulse from the drive laser is long enough, it’s relatively easy to create trains of attosecond pulses, one after the other. What’s hard is to make an individual attosecond pulse. Only four or five groups in the world have done it.”
Leone’s group, in partnership with Neumark’s, is one of those, and they have achieved individual attosecond pulses in a new way. The most frequently used method for making attosecond pulses depends on filters that select the highest-frequency slice of the harmonic pulse, which rides along with the most energetic half-cycle wave in the carrier pulse envelope. But Leone and Neumark, with their students and postdocs, used a method called ionization gating.
Ionization gating begins with a much more intense optical pulse – one so intense that the front of the pulse envelope knocks electrons right off the atoms in the gas, forming a dense plasma through which the pulse must plow. Not all the gas atoms are ionized, however; recombination of energized electrons and atoms still creates attosecond pulses of x-rays, but there’s a switch-like termination of the pulse train.
The “switch” is a process called phase match gating. The attosecond pulses, produced on the leading edge of the optical pulse, are tunable in x-ray energy by adjusting the phase of the half cycles within the driver pulse envelope. The attosecond pulses need not be locked to the strongest half-cycle in the optical pulse envelope.
Once the train has been terminated, the individual attosecond pulses, along with the original laser beam, continue on to a separate interaction region of the laser set-up, where experiments can be carried out.
Watching what happens in an attosecond
Once the attosecond pulses have entered the interaction region, Leone uses techniques called “carrier-envelope phase scanning” and “optical streaking” to observe what happens. With these he can identify and characterize individual attosecond pulses.
Carrier-envelope phase scanning: When an electron is boosted away from an atom during ionization, the photon that does the boosting consists of an electric field varying in one direction and then another. These fields can both add to and subtract from the electron’s momentum, so depending on when it is born, the photoelectron experiences a different force – sometimes stronger, sometimes weaker. Scanning the gas in the interaction region (whatever gas is the subject of the experiment) allows the timing of the electrons produced by the attosecond bursts to be identified by their extra momentum.
Optical streaking: A subsequent streak spectrogram compares the energy of the attosecond pulse to the energy of the photoelectron, as the two change over time. The streak spectrogram confirms the existence of individual attosecond pulses, measures their length, and determines when a secondary electron is produced.
“We have measured 450 attosecond pulses,” says Leone. “The time is limited by the particular optics used to reflect the x-rays. The method can actually produce much shorter pulses, tunable to various frequencies.”
Someday the method will deliver stability, reliability, and ease of use in the production of attosecond pulses, although at present Leone’s experimental laser system in Building 2 is still finicky. Leone compares it to a “TV set that’s a little temperamental; it works, but you have to have the touch.”
Even with this oversensitive instrument, Leone’s group has done unique scientific experiments on gas-phase samples. Using attosecond x-rays as pump pulses to ionize a thin gas of sulfur hexafluoride (SF6), they follow up with precisely timed probe pulses from the longer-wavelength, femtosecond laser beam, using ionization spectroscopy to see what happens as the molecules “evolve” – that is, as the sulfur compounds fall apart in an ordered routine dictated by nature. Knowing how nature does it could lead to control of such complex processes.
Practically next door to Leone’s lab in Building 2, Robert Kaindl of the Materials Sciences Division also uses an attosecond laser, disentangling electronic correlations in nanoparticles and complex materials. Meanwhile, Leone and Neumark pursue solid state physics at another lab on the UC Berkeley campus, studying such phenomena as excitons (the bound states of negatively charged electrons with positively charged holes). This work is vital to developing better solar cells, since excitons are important precursors to the separation of charges in semiconductors for converting sunlight to electrical current.
The science is so promising that other attosecond laser systems are already in the works. In January the W. M. Keck Foundation awarded $1 million to Leone and Neumark to upgrade a campus laboratory for attosecond science. Shortly thereafter the Department of Defense awarded Leone a National Security Science and Engineering Faculty Fellowship amounting to $850,000 per year over five years. “The Keck grant will go for equipment and the DOD award will fund operations, supplementing the generous support from the Department of Energy,” he says.
The ultrafast light sources of the future
Already on the horizon are powerful light sources able to generate ultrabright attosecond pulses of x-rays up to a million times a second, using some combination of linear accelerators, advanced electron injectors, and free electron lasers (FELs).
When he was with Berkeley Lab’s Accelerator and Fusion Research Division, Sasha Zholents (who is now at Argonne’s Advanced Photon Source) devised a laser pulse-slicing scheme using wiggler magnets, now used by the Advanced Light Source to produce femtosecond x-ray beams. He also pioneered a similar concept to produce attosecond pulses. The Zholents schemes “were the precursors to attosecond hopes for FELs,” Leone says.
High intensity, FEL-produced attosecond pulses, which may be made by such machines as Berkeley Lab’s proposed Next Generation Light Source, will be crucial to using attosecond pulses for both pump pulses and (until now impractical) probe pulses as well. Only in this way will it become possible to create and control the states of matter and chemical processes that theorists can visualize and model with computers.
“There are challenging problems with all the many techniques involved with attosecond science,” Leone says. “The strength of my own contributions lies in thinking about new ways to make the measurements and the science to be done with these short pulses.”
More about Steve Leone’s research
More about Dan Neumark’s research
More about the Keck Foundation’s $1 million award to Leone and Neumark for attosecond science
More about Leone’s National Security Science and Engineering Faculty Fellowship from the Department of Defense
More about free electron lasers and light sources of the future
Steve Leone defines “attosecond” in Berkeley Lab’s Video Glossary
“Time-resolved spectroscopy of attosecond quantum dynamics,” by Thomas Pfeifer, Mark J. Abel, Phillip M. Nagel, Aurélie Jullien, Zhi-Heng Loh, M. Justine Bell, Daniel M. Neumark, and Stephen R. Leone, appears in Chemical Physics Letters and is available online to subscribers.
“Isolated attosecond pulses from ionization gating of high-harmonic emission,” by Mark J. Abel, Thomas Pfeifer, Phillip M. Nagel, Willem Boutu, M. Justine Bell, Colby P. Steiner, Daniel M. Neumark, and Stephen R. Leone, appears in Chemical Physics and is available online to subscribers.